Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Robert A Mosher (he/him)'s avatar

My best hopes and prayers for the people of Sudan, but I remember that I have a book on my shelves by Edgar O'Ballance called The Secret War in the Sudan, 1955-1972, reflecting how long this conflict has carried on during my lifetime. I fear it's roots and the pattern of conflict can be seen in even much older history.

Expand full comment
Dr Tara Slatton's avatar

“Helping others matters if we want to be a powerful nation. While we should root out corruption, we should remember what matters.”

The thing is why should we want to be a powerful nation? Why can’t we be a prosperous nation who cares for our own first, and then once our own are cared for, who can care for others out of our excess? Nobody tells Switzerland that they have a duty to be a powerful nation and thus must invest billions in foreign aide. Switzerland is just fine and somehow manages to wield a lot of soft power. Nobody tells the Scandanavian countries that they need to become powerful nations.

I see a solid argument for giving out of our excess, however we have a $1.83 trillion deficit and every thing the federal government is ostensibly supposed to do for the American people is under funded and falling apart. It is one thing to give from abundance, it is entirely different to be forced to sacrifice for others. It is deeply immoral to force the single mom in Chicago who got crappy maternal care in the U.S. to pay for maternal care in Sudan. It is wrong to force retirement age shop workers in rural America to pay for agricultural development in Africa (or anywhere else).

Americans in general have no responsibility to care for the rest of the world when they cannot care for their own. Nobody else is going to care for our poor. Europe isn’t going to give us infrastructure grants.

We murder a million babies a year in this country and have more than half a million homeless people on the streets yet running hospitals in Sudan is suppose to give us some sort of moral capital?

American Christians absolutely have a duty to support their brothers and sisters in Sudan, as do Christians throughout the world. We are not doing as well as we could in that regard. However it seems deeply unjust to claim that the average American owes something to the rest of the world so we can remain “powerful”.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts